A recipe for tapioca would be as germane to the NFL protests as the Selma march. There is no definable law, principle or position these protests bring into focus. Let’s check the Ethics Alarms Protest Ethics Checklist against the NFL grandstanding:
1. Is this protest just and necessary?
No. How is it just? How is it necessary?
2.Is the primary motive for the protest unclear, personal, selfish, too broad or narrow?
Unclear and too broad by definition, since no two protesters make the same argument.
3. Is the means of protest appropriate to the objective?
Obviously not. What does football have to do with “racial justice”?
4. Is there a significant chance that it will achieve an ethical objective or contribute to doing so?
None whatsoever.
5. What will this protest cost, and who will have to pay the bill?
It’s already cost the NFL millions. But nobody is protesting the NFL…
6. Will the individuals or organizations that are the targets of the protest also be the ones who will most powerfully feel its effects?
No.
7. Will innocent people be adversely affected by this action? (If so, how many?)
Sure: every single fan who wants to just watch football.
8. Is there a significant possibility that anyone will be hurt or harmed? (if so, how seriously? How many people?)
The relentless politicizing of sports and entertainment harms U.S. society and frays the fabric of democracy. That means everyone.
9. Are you and your group prepared to take full responsibility for the consequences of the protest?
Clearly not: witness the constant complaining that NFL teams won’t hire Kaepernick so their season is dominated by racial politics rather than, you know, football..
10. Would an objective person feel that the protest is fair, reasonable, and proportional to its goal?
No.
11. What is the likelihood that the protest will be remembered as important, coherent, useful, effective and influential?
My guess: no chance whatsoever, unless unintended consequences count, like getting more votes for President Trump and crippling the NFL count.
12. Could the same resources, energy and time be more productively used toward achieving the same goals, or better ones?
It’s hard to imaging what wouldn’t be a better use of resources, energy and time.