Home > NewsRelease > Obesity Isn’t a Simple Matter of Diet and Exercise?—?It’s More Complex
Text
Obesity Isn’t a Simple Matter of Diet and Exercise?—?It’s More Complex
From:
Dr. Patricia A. Farrell -- Psychologist Dr. Patricia A. Farrell -- Psychologist
For Immediate Release:
Dateline: Tenafly, NJ
Monday, July 21, 2025

 
Photo by i yunmai on Unsplash

How many times have you been told you need to go on a diet or that you need to lose weight? Your physician, a dietitian, or a well-meaning friend may have even told you this. But now we know it’s not as simple as everyone has been led to believe. The issue of obesity is receiving new attention as research points to more complexity.

Obesity is one unified medical issue found throughout multiple decades and healthcare professionals use the BMI as their gold standard. The BMI calculation on the scale determines your health status, which results in three categories: normal weight, overweight, or obese. Seems pretty simple, doesn’t it?

But there’s a problem here, and probably more than one issue, because the BMI is not a good measure of weight. How many people know that it was originally used to evaluate slaves? Who constructed this scale? It wasn’t a doctor or other health professional — a Belgian mathematician. A mathematician? Where’s the medical knowledge there?

Research conducted in 2025 appears to have disproven the simplistic perspective by demonstrating that obesity exists in eleven separate conditions, each carrying unique biological signatures and different health consequences.

The discovery has the potential to transform our understanding of weight and health, as well as the definition of health across various body sizes. When we consider that weight is a significant health issue and that the weight-control industry is a billion-dollar endeavor, we can appreciate what these new findings may mean.

The Obesity Revolution

Scientists analyzed genetic data from over 2 million people across six different ancestry groups to conduct the largest and most diverse study of obesity. These scientists discovered obesity involves more than just excess weight because different biological processes operate throughout the bodies of people with obesity. Is it any wonder now that too many patients are being condemned for their eating habits and lack of exercise?

The Types of Obesity

Here’s where it gets really interesting. Research identified distinct “obesity endotypes” which are different biological pathways that result in weight gain. Some of the main obesity endotypes include:

  1. “The Metabolically Healthy” Type: These people maintain good blood sugar control and healthy cholesterol levels together with good insulin sensitivity despite their weight. Their bodies store fat in safer locations such as their hips and thighs instead of organs, and they face reduced risks for heart disease and diabetes than would be expected.

2. “The Metabolically Unhealthy” Type: This group stores fat dangerously close to liver and internal organs. Such individuals experience elevated dangers of developing diabetes and heart disease and various secondary medical issues. The brain system controlling hunger and energy homeostasis functions poorly. Current literature suggests that men with cardiac conditions are experiencing waistline expansion, which may be related to how their bodies store fat.

3. “The Strong Beta Cell Type”: These people have superhero pancreases. Their pancreas cells produce increased insulin levels to combat insulin resistance before diabetes develops. The body has an automatic backup power system that starts during a power outage to provide electricity.

4. “The Beta Cell Failure Types”: Some people have the opposite problem. When their pancreas fails to meet insulin requirements, their bodies develop diabetes at an earlier stage, while weight gain begins at a young age.

5. “The Immune System Type”: People within this category experience problems with their immune system that affect their fat storage and metabolic processes. The security system malfunctions in this condition thus producing inflammation and metabolic disorders throughout the body.

Why This Matters for Your Health

The scientific discoveries about weight and diet have immediate health effects that should guide your weight management strategies.

First, it explains why diets work differently for different people. I can remember participating as a consultant in a weight-control group. Some women lost a significant amount of weight, while others had a more difficult time losing weight.

Your results from the same weight loss program differ from your friend’s because you possess different obesity endotypes. Therefore, diet success depends on individual biology rather than discipline levels. As a psychologist, I can tell you this has a significant effect on people’s lives and self-esteem. They berate themselves when it’s their body’s biology that handles weight control, not necessarily them.

I’ve worked in hospitals where patients were prescribed mood-elevating medications. As a result, they gained weight, and the dietitian in the hospital placed them in groups that should change their behavior. It wasn’t their behavior that needed changing; it was their biology, but staff refused to recognize that.

Second, it challenges the stigma surrounding weight. The genetic makeup of specific individuals can create difficulties in managing weight because their brain systems do not function properly for hunger control, and their bodies store fat inefficiently.

As the new research shows, biological factors, rather than personal willpower, determine weight. We need to question whether eating is a learned behavior or a biologically controlled behavior. It may not be excessive eating at all; it may simply be eating. It might not matter whether you overeat if you are obese.

Third, it opens the door for personalized treatments. Medical professionals can now tailor their approach to each individual, as they have the possibility to identify specific types of obesity and create individualized treatments. The question is whether enough healthcare professionals will not only be aware of this research, but also know how to use it with each patient.

The Brain Connection

The research revealed that brain mechanisms control every type of obesity, making it one of its most interesting discoveries. All endotypes exhibited connections to brain mechanisms that regulate hunger, as well as metabolism and energy equilibrium. The scientific evidence confirms obesity represents a multifaceted neurobiological condition instead of personal failure or weak self-control.

Your body maintains energy equilibrium through the operation of your small yet powerful hypothalamus brain region, which functions as your internal thermostat. Some individuals have a malfunctioning thermostat that persistently sends signals for fat storage.

What This Means for You

The weight-related research presents both therapeutic possibilities together with useful practical knowledge for you:

  1. Stop blaming yourself: Your weight problems stem from biological origins that exceed fundamental issues of eating too much and not moving enough.

2. Examine the genetic patterns that exist within your family lineage: These endotypes exhibit genetic elements that are prominent in their makeup. Look at patterns in your family — not just weight, but diabetes, heart disease, and metabolic health.

3. Your focus should be on tracking your health indicators instead of weight measurements: When you belong to the “metabolically healthy” category your blood pressure readings and cholesterol levels and blood sugar measurements become more important than your weight status.

4. Be patient with different approaches: Each person requires unique approaches for weight loss because what works for one individual does not necessarily work for another person. Your approach to weight management does not signify failure.

Looking Forward

Genetic testing tools will help people identify their endotype type in the future. We have not yet reached the stage where doctors can include “obesity type” tests in annual physical exams, but scientific progress continues toward this goal. I know that this means waiting, and in the interim, you need to do a little of cognitive reframing. Consider your weight in relation to various factors rather than focusing solely on your food intake.

This research now shapes medical professionals’ approaches to treating obesity. Future obesity treatments could utilize genetic testing in conjunction with personalized nutritional plans and targeted medications tailored to individual biological characteristics.

The most important takeaway? That you have been struggling with your weight does not make you broken, lazy, or weak-willed. Your body functions as an intricate biological system, which requires empathy instead of condemnation.

The one-size-fits-all approach to obesity treatment has reached its end. The future of weight and metabolic health management through precision medicine has started its development.

 

Author's page: http://amzn.to/2rVYB0J

Medium page: https://medium.com/@drpatfarrell

Attribution of this material is appreciated.

Pickup Short URL to Share
News Media Interview Contact
Name: Dr. Patricia A. Farrell, Ph.D.
Title: Licensed Psychologist
Group: Dr. Patricia A. Farrell, Ph.D., LLC
Dateline: Tenafly, NJ United States
Cell Phone: 201-417-1827
Contact Click to Contact
Other experts on these topics